Sometimes wanting a different life does not mean your current one is bad. If you keep asking yourself, “Why do I want a different life when my life is good?” you may be asking the wrong question. You may have outgrown part of it, or want something it can’t give you. The more useful question is what you actually want to change, before you assume you need to change everything.

I learned that twice. The first time, I was 22 and leaving the United States. The second time, I was almost 28 and leaving a life in Thailand that looked pretty close to perfect. The second one was much harder to explain.

My life in Thailand was good

By then, I had lived in Thailand for almost five years. I had a decent job teaching science, and I lived in Krabi, the kind of place people save photos of when they plan a dream vacation. I had a motorbike, beaches nearby, familiar restaurants and a life I knew how to navigate. A lot of it genuinely was good, and that was what made leaving complicated.

There was no dramatic breaking point. I didn’t hate Thailand, I wasn’t desperate to escape my job, and I wasn’t miserable every day. I just kept thinking, this can’t be it. I had dreams I wasn’t working on and a feeling that there was more I was supposed to do with my life. Eventually, that feeling became harder to ignore than my reasons to stay.

Paradise can still be lonely

I loved Krabi in a lot of ways, but I never felt like I found my people there. I had acquaintances, people I knew and could talk to. What I didn’t have were the close friendships where you automatically know who to call when you’re bored, lonely, upset or just want someone to sit beside you for a few hours.

Some days I would get on my motorbike and drive around trying to figure out what to do. I’d been to the beaches and the restaurants, done the day trips and learned the roads. I’d pass groups of friends and families on the beach and feel a little pang of envy. They had somewhere to be because they had people to be with. I often had somewhere beautiful to go and nobody I particularly wanted to call.

It was strange to feel lonely somewhere that looked so much like paradise. The pretty pictures weren’t lying, and the life underneath them wasn’t bad. A photograph just can’t tell you whether a life actually fits the person living it.

I had felt that pull before

The first time I remember feeling something similar was during my freshman year of university, when I spent two weeks in China. In Guilin, I met backpackers for the first time. When it was time to leave, I wasn’t just end-of-vacation sad. I wished there were some way for me to stay longer. I looked at those backpackers and thought, I want to be like them, without having any idea how people funded long trips, worked abroad or built lives outside the path I understood.

Years later, I moved to Thailand thinking it was temporary. I expected to return to the United States. Then I saw a completely different way of living, and going home didn’t feel right either. My soul didn’t feel right going back yet, so I stayed, and one year became five.

Then staying stopped feeling right too

This is the part that gets lost in a lot of conversations about changing your life: sometimes you get the thing you wanted and eventually realize you’re ready for something else. That doesn’t make the original decision a mistake. Thailand changed my life. It showed me I could build a life somewhere unfamiliar, start with very little, make terrible decisions, adjust and eventually create something that felt completely normal. More importantly, it taught me I could do it again. I didn’t have to stay somewhere forever just because it had once been exactly where I needed to be.

Toward the end of my time there, that quiet nagging feeling came back. Something was missing, and I started wondering whether I was staying because Thailand still fit me or because I had become good at living there. Those aren’t the same thing.

Someone I knew died

Around that time, a young woman I knew was killed by a truck. She had recently started a new job at a new school, and she was happy and excited about it. She had plans for the week and plans for the weekend. She went to work like people do every day, assuming there would be another day after that one. And then there wasn’t.

Her death changed the way I thought about time. I don’t mean that everyone should quit their job tomorrow, buy a plane ticket and live as though consequences don’t exist. Time being finite is not an excuse to be reckless. But it made one thing very hard for me to ignore: we make a lot of decisions as though there will always be a better time later. Next year. After this job. After I save more. After things calm down. After I feel completely ready.

Sometimes waiting is wise, and sometimes it’s necessary. And sometimes it’s simply easier than admitting there’s something you’ve wanted for years and you’re scared to find out what happens if you actually try. I didn’t want to reach 60 and still be thinking about something I had wanted to do at 28. So I left.

How do you know when it’s time to change your life?

I wish I had a scientific answer for this. I don’t. For me, there’s a difference between wanting something for three bad days and having the same thought quietly return for months or years. You ignore it and it comes back. You get busy and it comes back. You convince yourself your life is perfectly fine, and it still comes back.

Some people call that intuition. Some call it restlessness, and some call it a calling. The easiest way I know to describe my own experience is that your soul knows. That probably sounds ridiculous if you’ve never felt it. If you have, you probably know exactly what I mean.

But I don’t think that feeling is proof that you should immediately blow up your life. I think it’s evidence that something is worth investigating. Your soul can get your attention. Then your brain needs to help with the research.

Do you want a different life, or do you want something in your life to change?

This is the question I would ask much more seriously now than I did at 22, because moving countries is a very dramatic solution to problems that sometimes have much smaller answers. Looking back at Krabi, I can see that some of what I wanted had nothing to do with Thailand. I didn’t need a new country to have someone to call on a bad day. I needed people. I didn’t need a new country to work on the goals I kept putting off. I needed to actually start them.

Your version might look different. Maybe you don’t hate working, you hate that job. Maybe you don’t hate your city, you just haven’t taken a proper break in six years. Maybe you don’t want to move abroad permanently, you want three months somewhere unfamiliar. Maybe what you actually want is more freedom, more community, more challenge, more creativity, less work, a different pace, or proof that you’re still capable of changing your life. Those are different needs, and they lead to very different decisions. If moving abroad is one of the options you’re weighing, I wrote separately about how to decide whether you should move abroad.

A quiet coastal road beside the beach in Koh Lanta, Thailand
An ordinary day in Koh Lanta.

Some things are about the place. Some things come with you.

This is the other half of that question, and it’s the half people usually skip. A new country changes your surroundings. It doesn’t automatically change your habits, your fears or the way you handle being alone. When I left Thailand, the loneliness didn’t ease. I was still searching for my people.

What changed was that I was finally working on other goals at the same time. I had wanted to travel long-term since I was a teenager reading Nomadic Matt in 2009, and meeting actual backpackers in Guilin had made that kind of life feel real. Leaving gave me that. It didn’t give me community. Both things were true.

So before you decide what to change, ask yourself two questions. What would actually be different somewhere else? And what would I still be carrying when I got there? The answers don’t cancel the dream. They just tell you which parts of it a plane ticket can solve.

At 31, I would still listen to the feeling. I would just research better.

At 22, I was willing to jump and figure out where I landed. That worked out remarkably well in some ways, but it also meant I accepted opportunities I probably wouldn’t accept now. Today, I would research salaries more carefully, and I wouldn’t automatically take the first offer because I was grateful someone offered me something. I would look into housing, legal options, work, transportation, community and what normal life actually looks like, and I’d pay far more attention to whether an opportunity was good rather than whether it simply existed.

Experience hasn’t made me less willing to take risks. It’s made me more interested in taking better risks.

Before you move, test the Tuesday

If someone told me today, “I have a good life, but I can’t stop imagining another one,” I wouldn’t tell them to sell everything. I would tell them to test it, and if living somewhere else is the life they keep imagining, I would make the test as ordinary as possible.

Take a long break from work if you can and go for a month. Rent an apartment or a longer-stay place rather than somewhere designed for a three-night vacation. The point isn’t luxury. It’s having enough of a home base to grocery shop, do laundry and settle into a routine. Join a language class, too. An in-person class is ideal because it gives your week structure and puts you around the same people again and again. If that isn’t realistic, regular one-on-one lessons through italki can give you some of that structure before you go and while you’re there.

Then live it. Buy groceries, do laundry and take public transportation. Work if your legal situation and job permit it, or build enough structure into your days that you aren’t simply on vacation. Find a coffee shop you keep going back to. Have boring days. Have a Tuesday. Vacation tells you whether you enjoy a place. Tuesday tells you whether you might enjoy a life there.

And on that Tuesday, ask yourself the question Krabi taught me to ask: If this were my life, who would I call tonight? If the answer is nobody yet, that doesn’t mean the place is wrong. It means you now know what you would have to build. That’s why I treat building community after moving abroad as part of the plan, not something to figure out after the boxes are unpacked. Pay attention to what’s left once the novelty wears off. That answer is much more useful than whether a destination looked good on Instagram.

If you can’t leave for a month, test it smaller

Not everyone can take a month off. Maybe you have parents who need you, a partner, a dog, a mortgage or a job that doesn’t bend. If your life already has roots, moving abroad in your 30s brings a different set of tradeoffs than it did at 22. That doesn’t leave you with only two options, stay forever or disappear. You can still test the Tuesday in smaller ways:

  • Spend a long weekend in one neighborhood and live like you’re staying. No sightseeing checklist.
  • Take a week or two and build it around a class, a routine, or remote work you’re allowed to do there.
  • Talk to two or three women who actually live in the place you keep imagining. Ask them what their ordinary weeks look like.
  • Look up what a normal month would cost you there, and compare it to your real life, not your vacation budget.

None of these will give you the full answer, but each one gives you more information than wondering.

Your current life doesn’t have to become the villain

I think this is where people get stuck. We assume a major change needs a dramatic justification: a terrible boss, a breakup, a financial crisis, burnout, some obvious event that makes leaving understandable to everyone else. But sometimes nothing is terribly wrong. Sometimes the life is good, and you’re just done with that version of it.

Thailand wasn’t a mistake I needed to correct. I loved it, and I’m still grateful I stayed so much longer than I originally planned. But eventually, loving Thailand and knowing it was time to leave became true at the same time, and those truths didn’t cancel each other out. You don’t have to convince yourself that your current life is awful before you’re allowed to get curious about another one.

If your life is good but you keep wondering about another one

I think you should find out what that feeling is asking for, which is different from saying you should automatically leave. Maybe you test another city for a month and realize you miss home. Maybe you take a sabbatical and discover that travel wasn’t the thing you actually wanted. Maybe you change jobs and the desire to move disappears. Or maybe you go somewhere for one month and finally understand why you’ve been thinking about it for five years. Any of those answers is useful.

There’s another kind of discomfort that comes from never testing the question at all. It’s quieter, and it comes back every few years: What if I had tried? For me, that question is harder to live with.

Your life doesn’t have to be terrible before you’re allowed to question it. It can be beautiful, comfortable, even the life you once desperately wanted, and still not be where you’re supposed to stay. If that quiet nagging feeling has been following you for years, you don’t need to blow up your life tomorrow. But I do think you owe yourself the chance to find out what it’s trying to tell you.

Your next step

Find out what the feeling is about.

Before you book, quit, stay or talk yourself out of wanting more, work through 30 Questions to Ask Yourself Before Moving Abroad. It’s free, and it helps you sort out whether this is about the place, the life or something you can change from right where you are.

You’ll join the NomaReina email list. Unsubscribe anytime.

Know someone feeling this?

Send them this post.

Affiliate disclosure: The Stay22 and italki links in this article are affiliate links. If you use one, NomaReina may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. I only place affiliate links where they make sense for the experiment or decision being discussed.